Battle of the Bad Guys: Round 1 – Hans Gruber vs. Bill the Butcher

Hans Gruber vs. Bill the Butcher

Time to kick off the Battle of the Bady Guys with two iconic villains, so I’m not making it easy. Time to cast your vote!

Hans Gruber

Hans Gruber

This is the villain in the first Die Hard, leader of a group of terrorists who take some people hostage in a skyscraper in order to free others who are in prison. Secretly it’s a plot to reach another goal, but he didn’t count on John McClane.

versus

Bill the Butcher

Bill the Butcher

Responsible for killing Amsterdam Vallon’s father, Bill the Butcher is a master with his knives and a frightening presence.

Which bad guy is your favorite? Please vote and let others know why you chose that specific bad guy in the comments.
[polldaddy poll=5619115]

24 thoughts on “Battle of the Bad Guys: Round 1 – Hans Gruber vs. Bill the Butcher

    • I will refrain from voting myself (I want to be the objective referee ;)), but I would have a hard time picking one as they both are awesome characters.

  1. I vote Gruber. Bill the Butcher is all intimidation. Hans, meanwhile, showed a prowess for quick thinking and clever scheming. Plus, in a fight between the two, Gruber would have access to better weapons.

    • That currently puts Gruber in the lead! I like your reasoning. I imagine a scene between them which would play out like that scene in Raiders of the Lost Ark where he uses his gun on a bad guy 😉

      • Yeah, pretty much! Bill would be doing his knifey eye-tapping thing, and then Gruber would just shoot him and move on.

        I feel like I’m being too hard on Bill. I really dig that character, and DDL was great in the role. Still, I stand by my Gruber vote.

  2. Hi, Nostra and company:

    Great to see you’re bringing out the big guns right away!

    I went with Hans Gruber.

    Bill the Butcher had the gestures, tics and soliloquies to run a street mob through fear and reputation.

    Hans Gruber had the style, charming charisma, fashion sense and seductive sociopathy so needed and desired in today’s upper management, media savvy villain.

  3. I guess I might be one of the few who voted for Bill the Butcher. I just love Day Lewis performance in that role. Either of these could win and I’d be happy though.

  4. Gotta go with Bill the Butcher. Hans Gruber is one cunning SOB but I wouldn’t want to get gutted by DDL while he screams “I drink your milkshake!”

  5. I haven’t seen There Will Be Blood though from the reviews Bill sounds like a real evil man. I’d go with Gruber for that reason and because I LOVE Alan Rickman 🙂

  6. Just casted by vote – it went to Bill the Butcher. I agree with Eric, I would definitely not want to get on the wrong side of Bill. The man has definitely got a screw or two loose, and it was another great performance by Daniel Day Lewis.

  7. Pingback: Battle of the Bad Guys: Round 1 – Hannibal Lecter vs. Keyser Söze « My Filmviews

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *